Stuart Baggs – your brand is out of control

I’m not claiming to have come up with the notion that your customers write your brand and your employees write your company culture, but it’s one I keep coming back to.

If the brand is a promise – setting the expectation of an experience – then to be fulfilled, someone needs to experience it. It is a relationship. It is a conversation.

As a social media agency, we are used to talking to organisations about where those conversations are happening. Those conversations are the myriad instances where brands are being experienced by consumers. Where once that experience happened offline and in private, now that experience is lived out and communicated online. The old notion of controlling your brand message is getting dusty.

Nowhere is there a better illustration for how brand control is an anachronism than on the current series of The Apprentice. Stuart Baggs, would have us believe that he is the future of entrepreneurship. He made millions selling conkers in the playground. Everything he touches, apparently, turns to sold. “I’m Stuart Baggs ‘The Brand’ – I’ve got a certain type of charisma,” he told us. His leadership style has got some in the blogosphere thinking – not just Nick Hewer.

I wanted to see what other viewers thought so I did an analysis of conversations on Twitter. Evaluating the conversations happening about him over the last week would suggest that somewhere along the line, his positive messages have not hit home quite how he was intending. On Twitter, just in the last week, of the conversations tracked by Social Mention, only 12% were positive. 32% were neutral and an overwhelming 56% were negative. Although I was tempted to add in a new sentiment category of mickey-taking as this was a recurrent theme.

Based on performance, tonight is the night that Stuart Baggs ought to get fired. But for car-crash-telly-value, I suspect he might be around for a little longer.

Latest Posts

Every social platform has a “star” content format, the one that gets the most eyes, likes, and shares. The trick? Not just posting in that format but designing it so it feels like it belongs there while still screaming your brand. Let’s break it down, platform by platform. Instagram: Reels…
Read More
The way travellers plan and book trips has shifted dramatically and it’s reshaping how brands need to show up. For years, we thought about the customer journey as a funnel. Today, it’s nothing like that. Discovery is messy, fragmented, and often happens across half a dozen platforms before a traveller…
Read More
If you’re trying to grow your Instagram account, you’ve probably asked yourself: How often should I post? According to a recent study by Buffer, the simple answer is — the more, the better. Buffer, a social media management platform, analysed over 2 million posts from 100,000 Instagram accounts. They wanted…
Read More